Colleen's Mistake

Colleen's Mistake
Colleen's Mistake
Colleen's Mistake
Colleen's Mistake

$30.00 for

Colleen's Mistake

This pie is a result of a delicious mistake that happened one day in the bakery and is here to stay! Our Double Butter Crust is filled with a rich chocolate fudge centre and topped with maple candied salted pecans, house made whipped cream and caramel sauce. Similar to a Turtle Pie, only way better. This has quickly become The Pie Hole's favourite mistake.

Step 1: Select Size



3" (9-pack)



Step 2: Click Add to Cart


  • Pecans
  • Chocolate
  • Butter
  • Eggs
  • Maple Syrup
    Maple Syrup

Butter, Flour, White Sugar, Chocolate, Cream, Nutella, Vanilla, Eggs, Pecans, Maple Syrup, Maldon Sea Salt, Icing Sugar, Cream Stabilizer, Brown Sugar 

Ordering Details

Step 1: Select a size (this one's easy, only 9" available!)

Step 2: Select either Fresh or Frozen (note: Frozen not available for all pies).

Step 3: Click “Add to Cart” and, if you are done shopping, proceed to Checkout.

Your order will be freshly made and ready for you on the date specified by the fundraising organizer!

We take great pride in making each pie from scratch, by hand, and from locally sourced ingredients of the finest quality. Should you be unhappy with your pie, please let us know by contacting

Please note:

- Orders cannot be changed, nor cancelled, with less than 48 hours to delivery. Please contact to make changes to your existing order.

- All of our products contain eggs, dairy, sugar and gluten unless otherwise noted. Our products are made in a facility that contains milk, nuts and gluten and, while we take great care to avoid it, cross contamination may occur in a food preparation area.